Analyst Questions Liverpool Midfield Balance Amid Defensive Metrics Gap
Transfer Market Metrics analysis suggests the Reds lack a defensive anchor, with Ryan Gravenberch and Dominik Szoboszlai identified as ill-suited for their current roles.
Dr Phil Barts, appearing on the Transfer Market Metrics special for Anfield Index, has cast doubt on the structural integrity of Liverpool’s midfield, arguing that individual quality does not equate to tactical balance. Speaking alongside Dave Davis, Barts acknowledged the squad’s capacity to control possession and create chances but warned that these attributes are undermined by significant defensive deficiencies when measured against elite competitors.
The analysis focused heavily on the configuration used against Monaco, where Florian Wirtz operated as the number 10 and Ryan Gravenberch and Dominik Szoboszlai formed the double pivot. Barts argued that the current setup leaves the team exposed, noting that Liverpool’s midfielders often operate without adequate cover during defensive transitions. This stands in stark contrast to the approach of rivals Arsenal, who Barts noted consistently cover critical defensive actions with two players, whereas Liverpool’s unit is frequently left to manage situations with none or only one supporter.
Defensive metrics provided the core of Barts’ critique. He highlighted that Liverpool’s midfielders trail both Arsenal and Manchester City in recoveries, interceptions, and tackles, placing them in a percentile lower than expected for an elite centre-midfield unit. Barts pointed out that Manchester City’s Rodri consistently outperforms Liverpool’s three-man midfield in these key defensive statistics, suggesting a systemic issue rather than individual underperformance.
The discussion also turned to the progressive passing abilities of Gravenberch and Szoboszlai. Barts criticised both players for preferring to carry the ball forward rather than executing progressive passes, a trait he identified as a problem off the ball. He described Gravenberch specifically as an attacking midfielder who had attempted to transition into a defensive number six role. While acknowledging Gravenberch did an acceptable job, Barts stated the player lacks the necessary instinct to protect the defence, effectively functioning as a number eight rather than a true anchor.
Davis, participating in the discussion, acknowledged the strengths of the current midfield but cautioned against dismissing the concerns. He noted that while the players are capable, the defensive situations warrant serious attention. Barts concluded that Liverpool currently has only one player performing at a top level in the midfield and has identified specific areas where no one is doing enough work. He called for a specific profile player to address these off-the-ball deficiencies, suggesting that the current squad composition is incomplete without a dedicated defensive specialist.
