Culture

Comedian Robby Hoffman ascends to global stardom amid controversy over unfiltered material

Hoffman's rapid rise follows a hit Netflix special and roles in Hacks and Rooster, drawing praise from John Mulaney despite backlash over jokes on sensitive topics

Author
Sofia Vale
Style and Culture Editor
Published
Draft
Source: The Guardian Culture · original
Culture
No image available
From accounting to Emmy nominations, the New York-born star defends her edgy style by citing a history of poverty

Robby Hoffman has rapidly ascended to become one of the world's most successful comedians, a trajectory marked by a hit Netflix special titled *Wake Up* and an Emmy-nominated role in the fifth season of *Hacks*. Her ascent is further cemented by a starring role opposite Steve Carell in the comedy *Rooster*. This commercial success arrives alongside significant controversy, as her unfiltered material addresses sensitive topics including abortion, paedophilia, and gender identity.

The special *Wake Up*, which was directed by John Mulaney, received public praise from the comedian who described Hoffman as a top-tier talent. Mulaney's endorsement highlights the industry's recognition of Hoffman's rapid rise, even as her punchlines make some audience members bristle. Hoffman defends this approach by stating that being offended isn't the worst thing, noting that being poor is far worse.

This philosophy is rooted in Hoffman's background growing up in a large Hassidic family in Montreal and Brooklyn. She was the seventh of 10 children in a household that relied on welfare payments, a history she draws upon to justify her unfiltered style. Having transitioned from a career in accounting to comedy, she now uses her platform to share thoughts she insists she cannot choose, arguing that it is more democratic to joke about everything.

Despite her boorish stage persona, Hoffman reveals she is currently in a relationship with reality TV star Gabby Windey, whom she met at a lesbian bar in Los Angeles three years ago. The pair share a home in Los Angeles and have become darlings of the LGBTQ+ community. Windey, a former star of *The Bachelorette*, reportedly understands Hoffman better through the show *Love on the Spectrum*, a series Hoffman watches with her wife.

Hoffman also identifies as a woman in a "genderqueer space" despite having undergone top surgery. She noted that using they/them pronouns would have been a viable option for her, though she stands by her gags on the topic. This refreshing honesty extends to her stance on industry issues; in 2023, she opposed the Writers Guild of America strike, arguing the union should have pursued litigation before striking. While her views initially resulted in her being booed by union members, she later described her timing as "autistic and off," noting she describes herself as autistic without an official diagnosis.

Off stage, Hoffman presents a softer, more tender tone, contrasting with the coarseness of her performances. She remains grateful for her success, viewing her journey from poverty to wealth as miraculous but resentful that others must be so special to achieve dignity. With her tour expanding and a new TV show in the works, Hoffman continues to allow herself to be as "me" as possible, refusing to spare anyone of anything.

Continue reading

More from Culture

Read next: Death of a Salesman makes history at 2026 Tony Awards
Read next: The quiet extinction of Australian sound
Read next: The pressure cooker: Mafs Australia stars allege coercive control and unsafe conditions