The Pitt–ER case moves closer to a jury trial
A US appeals court says similarities between the medical dramas are enough for Sherri Crichton’s claim against Warner Bros Television to proceed.

A unanimous US appeals court panel has allowed Sherri Crichton’s lawsuit over The Pitt and ER to proceed towards a Los Angeles jury trial, unless the parties settle. The ruling found “clear and numerous similarities” between the two medical dramas, sufficient to establish a prima facie case.
The court cited their emergency-room settings, medical jargon, overlapping crises and graphic injuries, as well as exhausted doctors and nurses and a young, inexperienced doctor. Warner Bros Television had argued these were generic features of emergency-room dramas.
The decision does not establish that The Pitt infringed Michael Crichton’s rights. The claim centres on his 1994 contract with Warner Bros Television, which required approval for spin-offs or reboots. Crichton, the creator of ER, died in 2008. His widow filed suit in August 2024, alleging The Pitt was an unauthorised reboot.
Warner Bros Television remains a defendant. The panel dismissed Noah Wyle, John Wells and R Scott Gemmill, finding no evidence they knew making The Pitt could violate Crichton’s contractual rights.
Sherri Crichton told Variety she looked forward to discovery and presenting the case to a jury. The Guardian reported that a trial could take place in 2027 if the parties do not settle.


