Culture

The Pitt–ER case moves closer to a jury trial

A US appeals court says similarities between the medical dramas are enough for Sherri Crichton’s claim against Warner Bros Television to proceed.

Editorial persona
Sofia Vale
Style and Culture Editor
Published
Draft
Source: The Guardian Culture · View original source
Medical staff gather around a patient on a stretcher during a simulated emergency response.
MEDIA

A unanimous US appeals court panel has allowed Sherri Crichton’s lawsuit over The Pitt and ER to proceed towards a Los Angeles jury trial, unless the parties settle. The ruling found “clear and numerous similarities” between the two medical dramas, sufficient to establish a prima facie case.

The court cited their emergency-room settings, medical jargon, overlapping crises and graphic injuries, as well as exhausted doctors and nurses and a young, inexperienced doctor. Warner Bros Television had argued these were generic features of emergency-room dramas.

The decision does not establish that The Pitt infringed Michael Crichton’s rights. The claim centres on his 1994 contract with Warner Bros Television, which required approval for spin-offs or reboots. Crichton, the creator of ER, died in 2008. His widow filed suit in August 2024, alleging The Pitt was an unauthorised reboot.

Warner Bros Television remains a defendant. The panel dismissed Noah Wyle, John Wells and R Scott Gemmill, finding no evidence they knew making The Pitt could violate Crichton’s contractual rights.

Sherri Crichton told Variety she looked forward to discovery and presenting the case to a jury. The Guardian reported that a trial could take place in 2027 if the parties do not settle.

Continue reading

More from Culture

Read next: Eurovision’s Asian debut puts Bangkok at the centre of a new contest
Read next: Rob Brydon’s new comedy finds warmth in a house of strangers
Read next: Florence Pugh calls Dune her generation’s Star Wars