The evidence behind a landmark UN report on carbon storage faces new scrutiny
A ProPublica and Drilled investigation says a confidential expert survey helped support key claims in a 2005 IPCC report. The technology’s ability to scale remains uncertain.

A 2005 report by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change helped establish carbon capture and storage (CCS) as a possible climate policy tool. A ProPublica and Drilled investigation now examines how its storage chapter reached conclusions about underground capacity and long-term retention, and whether those claims were supported by the evidence available at the time.
The investigation reports that chapter authors used a confidential expert survey to support estimates including that well-selected, well-managed sites could retain 99 per cent of stored carbon for at least 1,000 years. The survey was not cited in the report. The extent of its influence on the published conclusions is disputed.
Sally Benson, who helped lead the chapter, said she did not believe the survey breached IPCC norms and rejected claims that industry funding influenced her work. The IPCC said the process followed procedures in place at the time and reflected the contemporary understanding of the technology. It declined to comment on individual recollections.
The investigation also finds that large-scale CCS deployment has fallen short of expectations. It reports that 12 large-scale geological storage projects have been built since 1996, with seven facing technical, financial or performance problems. Project counts vary depending on whether enhanced oil recovery, which injects carbon dioxide to extract oil, is included.
The report’s findings have informed climate modelling and policy, according to the investigation. Whether CCS can expand enough to meet the scale assumed in some climate plans remains uncertain; the investigation’s assessment is not a consensus forecast.


