Missouri Republicans renew calls to change how top judges are selected
The proposals followed a court dispute over a Republican-backed congressional map. Any change to the state’s judicial selection system would require voter approval.

Missouri Republicans have renewed calls to replace the state’s 86-year-old system for selecting top judges after the state Supreme Court blocked a Republican-backed congressional map while voters consider it in a referendum.
Under the Missouri Plan, a commission shortlists three candidates for the governor to choose from for top judicial appointments. Judges later face retention votes. Alternatives raised by Republicans include electing Supreme Court judges or allowing the governor to nominate judges subject to Senate confirmation.
The dispute escalated after Secretary of State Denny Hoskins directed officials to use a new map despite the court’s order to restore the existing one until voters decide. The court held Hoskins in contempt; he then instructed local election officials to distribute ballots using the old map. The justices did not order his arrest. Fourteen Republican lawmakers had threatened impeachment if the court held him in contempt.
U.S. Rep. Jason Smith called for electing Supreme Court judges. State Rep. Cathy Jo Loy, who has introduced replacement bills in the past two sessions, said she plans to file another on 1 December. She said the court clashes could increase support. Gov. Mike Kehoe said changing judicial selection had not been on his radar before the ruling, but might now be discussed.
Missouri voters rejected an overhaul proposal by a 3-to-1 margin in 2012, and a later proposal to replace the system stalled in committee. Five of the Supreme Court’s seven judges were appointed by Republican governors.
No change has been enacted. Any replacement would need voter approval, and it remains unclear whether a proposal will advance or win enough support to reach a ballot.


