Barrie urges Australia to end AUKUS submarine plan
The former defence force chief says the inquiry received no evidence from government or opposition representatives, leaving key questions about the programme unanswered.

Former Australian Defence Force chief Chris Barrie has called for Australia to end the AUKUS submarine plan and develop a tested replacement for the Collins-class fleet. His recommendation appears in an inquiry report discussed in an opinion article published by The Guardian.
Barrie says the federal government, opposition and serving Australian Defence Organisation personnel did not give evidence to the inquiry after receiving written invitations. Community members, including First Nations Australians, raised concerns about costs, nuclear waste and planned submarine rotations at HMAS Stirling.
The Guardian article cites a projected AUKUS cost of more than $368 billion by the mid-2050s. Barrie says the government has not set out which missions the submarines would perform, how alternatives compare, or the costs and risks involved.
HMAS Stirling is due to host rotating US and UK nuclear-powered submarines from 2027. Barrie says up to $8 billion has been committed to expanding the base. He also points to an Australian Submarine Agency risk concerning the lack of a waste-disposal capability, saying the agency has set no target or timeline to address it.
The article says foreign submarines will be conventionally armed “for now” and raises questions about future arrangements. It does not establish that boats hosted at Stirling will carry nuclear weapons.
Barrie’s report recommends ending the AUKUS submarine plan and developing a properly assessed Collins-class replacement under full Australian command and control. The source package does not include the government’s response or independently verify the cost projections.


